Below are Noble Group Chairman Richard Elman's opening remarks at the 2014 AGM and shareholder Mano Sabnani's first question. You can read the riveting 37-page transcript in full at the SGX website.


richardelman4.15Richard Elman, 75.
Photo: Company
Ladies and gentlemen, I sincerely welcome you all to our shareholders’ meeting today.

It has been a difficult few weeks for all of us, including you our genuine shareholders, but we will put in all our effort to make sure that wrongs will be made right.

I want to make a few comments: Nothing that Noble has done has been shown to violate any accounting rules. Not a single independent analyst has called into question the honesty or legality of the accounts. Some have said they may be aggressive; some have said they are normal to the industry. People can and do take a view on these things. The point I want to make is, not a single qualified independent analyst has said that Noble has violated accounting or reporting standards.

We have recently found several hedge funds were canvassed proposing a profit focused shortselling venture target on Noble over the last year. It was only after the hedge funds reviewed the reports and found them not experienced or dependable enough, and rejected the business proposal, that were then morphed into a “public spirited whistle blower”. The “public spirited whistle blower status” was a direct result of his failure to be taken seriously as a for-profit short seller by sophisticated hedge funds. He apparently become public spirited only after being not taken seriously by the several professional short-sellers he spoke to.

As you can guess, I am talking about Iceberg.

I want to tell you sincerely that we are here to defend our people, our genuine shareholders from misinformation and attack.

The Iceberg issue is finished. We have started legal proceedings and we look forward to challenging their inaccurate, unreliable and misleading claims in a public court. We have a solid, highly liquid balance sheet and the backing of our stakeholders - Institutions, retail investors, banks, regulators and analysts. Our focus is firmly on running the business - to achieve our goal of becoming the leading mover of physical commodities in the world.

As the Chairman, with a significant shareholding in the Company myself, I feel aggrieved about what has happened over the past two months as you must do. We believe that all of the recent scaremongering has been carried out to deliberately drive our share price lower, to profit from short-selling. In a moment you’ll hear from our CEO, Yusuf Alireza, about the robust condition of your Company.

But first I’d like to reiterate, for the record, that we categorically reject all allegations made in the recent reports as inaccurate, unreliable and misleading. You cannot get a stronger statement from a publicly listed company.

So, to repeat once again: We consider the Iceberg matter finished. We have started legal proceedings and we look forward to challenging their inaccurate, unreliable and misleading claims in a public court. We don’t think there is a better venue to challenge these allegations than in front of a judge in a court which is open to the public.

The recent Muddy Waters report barely dignifies a response. It was short, it re-hashed an old allegation, it contained no new evidence and it used a very absurd behavioural analysis of one analyst phone call. The market was clear in its response to this short-selling report – our shares lost only 2% to the end of the week. But with their stated short position it is in their best interests to continue making false allegations against the Company. In the interests of protecting our shareholders from these reports, we have provided to these allegations with swift rebuttals posted to SGX. We will not, we will not be revisiting details of these allegations in this meeting.

Our Company, your company, is in a robust condition. Over the last 20 years we have grown from a revenue of $377m to $85bn. We have a solid, highly liquid balance sheet: $5.2 billion of liquidity headroom; Debt to capitalisation is at a historic low of 38%; $904m of cash at the year-end; our dividend payment to shareholders is now 35%, up from previous 25%. We have the backing of our stakeholders - institutions, retail investors, banks, regulators and analysts. Our banks are organising normal revolving credit facilities of $2.25bn. Of 16 analysts who cover us ten have buy calls, with six having hold calls. There is not a single sell call.

So, our focus now is firmly on running the business and we will not be sidetracked by people who are trying to deviate us from doing that. We need to achieve our goal of becoming the leading mover of physical commodities in the world.

I will now like to hand over to our CEO, Mr Alireza, who will give you a powerpoint presentation and an update of the Company’s activities. Thank you very much for listening to me. [Applause]


283mano_agm_12Mano Sabnani, 65. NextInsight file photo.Good morning, my name is Mano, Chairman. I am a shareholder for some time. I’d like to first congratulate on a much better organized meeting today – bigger place, which last year I last spoke about, it is better. I have great respect for you, Mr Chairman, having grown the company from what it was 20 years ago. So I hope you don’t mind if I give you some frank impressions, questions and suggestions as well.

[Richard Elman: as long as they are directly related to the proposition.]

It’s all about the results.

[Richard Elman: We would like to have questions, not statements, if possible.]

My questions are twofold – I would like to refer you to page 62 and 63, and this is the financial summary of the Noble Group.

My points are that, looking at these results, if you look, it is all the way from 2005 to last year. What I can see from this is that number 1, your revenues have grown and I heard the CEO mentioning several times “records, records”, but the “records” refers to revenue.

Number 2, the liabilities have gone up and up and up. On the other hand, the profits actually, we are where we were at 2006, that is almost 10 years ago. And I noticed that in your annual report, although you have a lot of data, but you don’t provide key numbers that shareholders would actually be interested in, and I think that is what Noble needs to look at.

To look at profitability, to be honest with shareholders and give them these ratios, you know. Because the picture that comes across, is that your business has grown in terms of volumes, but your margins are not really what they used to be, and in 2006, for example, your equity base was much smaller and you could do the same level of profits. In subsequent years, your equity base grew but your profits grew much faster.


Comments  

+2 #1 Aquarius 2015-04-22 21:40
Somehow I seem to be reminded of the Enron Scandal of 2001 which was a big audit failure that led to the collapse of Enron and its public auditors Arthur Anderson. The operations of the group was cloaked in very complex financial statements which, among other things, involved misrepresentati on of income recognition.

Caveat emptor : Adolf Hitler once said "The greater the lie, the more readily it will be believed".
Quote

Share Prices

Counter NameLastChange
AEM Holdings3.450-0.110
Avi-Tech Electronics0.280-
Best World2.4300.080
Broadway Ind0.1140.006
China Sunsine0.470-0.005
DISA0.002-0.001
Food Empire0.710-
Fortress Minerals0.360-0.010
Geo Energy Res0.330-0.010
Golden Energy0.790-0.005
GSS Energy0.048-
InnoTek0.505-0.010
ISDN Holdings0.570-0.020
ISOTeam0.099-
IX Biopharma0.122-
Jiutian Chemical0.081-0.002
KSH Holdings0.340-
Leader Env0.062-
Medtecs Intl0.158-0.005
Meta Health0.024-
Nordic Group0.4750.005
Oxley Holdings0.148-
REX International0.225-0.005
Riverstone0.675-0.010
Sinostar PEC0.185-
Southern Alliance Mining0.6000.005
Straco Corp.0.5100.010
Sunpower Group0.370-0.010
The Trendlines0.095-0.001
Totm Technologies0.113-
UG Healthcare0.182-0.005
Uni-Asia Group0.8900.015
Wilmar Intl4.100-0.030
Yangzijiang Shipbldg1.250-0.020

NextInsight RSS

rss_2 NextInsight - Latest News

Online Now

We have 921 guests and no members online